You just got back from a conference. Your phone's full of business cards, your email's got 50 new contacts, and you're feeling optimistic about all these "connections" you made.
Then reality hits - you have no idea what to do with any of them.
Most people send a generic "nice to meet you" email, maybe reference one thing you talked about, and call it a day. Then they're confused why nothing happens.
Here's the thing - the conference didn't close any deals. It just opened a door. What you do in the next 2-3 weeks is what actually matters. And most people fumble it completely.
Let's be honest about what's actually happening when you meet someone at a conference:
Your generic follow-up lands in that pile of noise. It doesn't stand out. It doesn't remind them why they should care.
The people who actually convert conference leads do something different. They treat the follow-up like a second conversation, not a checkbox task.
Send your follow-up within 24-48 hours. Not a week later. Not when you "get around to it." Within two days.
Here's why - their memory of you is still relatively fresh, and you're hitting their inbox before they've mentally moved on.
In that email, do three things:
Not "it was great talking to you about marketing." That could apply to anyone.
Something like - "I was thinking about what you mentioned about your team struggling with client onboarding - that's exactly what we see with most agencies your size."
Specific details make people feel like you actually paid attention. Because you did. This takes 30 seconds to write but signals that you're not spam.
Don't ask them to schedule a call yet. Don't ask them to do anything.
Send them something useful - a relevant article, a template, a resource that relates to a problem they mentioned. Something they can actually use in the next week without committing to anything.
This flips the dynamic. You're not another salesperson asking for their time. You're someone who actually thought about their situation and helped them out.
At the end, mention that you'll be following up in a week or so to see if that resource was helpful. That's it. You're setting expectations that you'll be in touch, and you're not being weird about it.
Most people send one email and call it done. That's why they get nothing.
You need to follow up 2-3 more times over the next 2-3 weeks. Not aggressively. Just consistently.
Week 1 - Initial follow-up with specific detail and value (as described above)
Week 2 - Short check-in. "Did that resource help? I came across this other thing that might be relevant to what you mentioned." Share another relevant piece of content or insight.
Week 3 - This is where you can actually pitch. "I think there's a real opportunity here to help you solve [specific problem]. Would it make sense to grab 15 minutes to talk about it?"
If they ghost after this, move on. But most people who ghosted weeks 1 and 2 will respond to week 3 because you've actually provided value, not just asked for their time.
Don't do these things - they destroy your conversion rate:
If you're doing this right, you should be converting 10-15% of your conference conversations into actual meetings or opportunities.
Some will convert immediately. Most will convert over 2-3 weeks. Some will take a month. Some will come back to you in 3 months when they actually need what you're selling.
The point is - you're staying on their radar in a way that feels helpful, not spammy. That's the whole game.
Because it takes time. It takes thoughtfulness. It's not a template you can batch out in 10 minutes.
But that's exactly why it works. Everyone else is sending generic follow-ups. You're actually building relationships.
If you went to a decent conference and met 20-30 people, and you convert even 3-4 of them into clients, that conference paid for itself three times over. Most people convert zero because they don't follow up properly.
Conference follow-up is simple in theory and annoying in practice. You have to remember to do it, remember to personalize it, remember to follow up multiple times, and stay consistent with it week after week.
Most service businesses and agencies struggle with this because it's one more thing competing for your attention when you're already swamped running the business.
If you want someone else handling the entire follow-up process - from personalizing each email to managing the sequence to handling replies - that's exactly what teams like BEC Growth do. They take conference leads and turn them into closed clients using cold email, so you don't have to manage it yourself.
But whether you do it yourself or outsource it, just do something. The leads you paid for by attending that conference are worth the effort.
Ready to Sign Clients On-Demand?
BEC Growth builds and manages your entire cold email system from infrastructure to reply handling.
Book a Call →