You're sitting on a solid product. Maybe you've built educational games for classrooms, or you've got a line of toys that retailers should be carrying. You know your stuff is good. But getting buyers, decision makers, and store owners to even open your emails? That's where most toy and game companies hit a wall.
The problem isn't your product. It's that nobody's expecting to hear from you, and your first message is competing with hundreds of other things in their inbox. Plus, in the toys and games space, the decision-making process is weird - it's not just about features or price. Retail buyers care about margins, seasonality, shelf space, and whether your product fits their existing catalog. That's a lot to navigate in a cold outreach.
Here's the good news: cold email works really well for this industry, but only if you understand what makes toy and game buyers actually respond.
This sounds obvious, but most people get this wrong. You can't send the same email to a Walmart buyer, a mom-and-pop toy store owner, and an online retailer. They have completely different priorities.
Start by picking one category and owning that first. Trying to reach everyone at once is how you end up with mediocre results everywhere.
Generic cold email doesn't work in this space. You need to speak directly to what keeps a buyer up at night.
For independent retailers, that's usually: Can this product move off shelves quickly? Will my customers actually buy it? Does it fit my store's vibe?
For educational buyers, it's: Will this help my students learn? Is it age-appropriate? Will parents support it?
For online retailers, it's: What's the margin? How fast can we get inventory? Is there demand for this?
Your email needs to answer at least one of these things in the first three sentences. Not in paragraph two. Not after they click a link. In the first three sentences.
"Hi [Name], I noticed you stock educational games for kids aged 4-7. We've got a new tile-based logic game that parents are buying at a 3.2x attach rate. Thought it might fit your store."
That's it. You've told them: you researched them, your product fits their niche, and there's social proof (the attach rate). Now they actually want to read the rest.
The toy and games industry has seasonal patterns. Q4 is massive. Back-to-school matters for educational products. Summer is different than winter.
If you're reaching out in July trying to sell Christmas toys, you're timing it wrong. If you're reaching out to schools in June, everyone's already planning their budget for the next year.
Know the buying calendar for your specific segment. Reach out 8-12 weeks before they typically make purchasing decisions. This alone will probably double your response rate.
Also - look at what makes specific retailers tick. An indie store that focuses on sustainable toys has different needs than one that specializes in action figures. Do 30 seconds of research. Mention what you found. People respond to being seen.
One email doesn't cut it. Most people need to see your message 3-5 times before they respond. But you can't just resend the same email.
Email 1 (Day 1): Your intro - product fit, proof point, specific ask (usually a call or demo).
Email 2 (Day 5): Light follow-up. Assume they missed it. Add one more detail - maybe a testimonial or a different angle on why your product matters.
Email 3 (Day 10): Different hook. Maybe focus on something you didn't mention in email 1. If email 1 was about margins, email 3 could be about customer demand or exclusivity.
Email 4 (Day 14): This is usually the breakup email or the "last chance" angle. Sometimes it's just genuine - "Hey, seems like this might not be the right fit, but let me know if circumstances change."
The key is spacing and variety. You're not being annoying - you're just staying top of mind while giving them new reasons to respond.
Trying to sell too hard in the first email. Toy and game buyers are used to cold outreach. They can smell desperation. Lead with curiosity and fit, not your sales pitch.
Not differentiating between buyer types. A mass email to 500 random retailers will fail. A targeted email to 50 retailers that actually match your product will win.
Forgetting that buying is personal. Even large retailers have individual buyers. Research them a little. Mention their store. Show you've actually looked at what they do.
Weak call to action. Don't say "Let me know if you'd like more info." Say "Can we grab 15 minutes next Tuesday or Wednesday to talk about this?" Specificity gets responses.
Cold email can generate real meetings and real deals for toy and game companies. But it requires targeting the right buyers, timing it right, understanding their specific pain points, and following up with purpose.
If you want to build this yourself, start with one buyer segment, test 20 emails, measure what actually gets responses, and iterate. It takes time and attention to detail, but it absolutely works.
If you'd rather have a team handle the whole thing - building the list, writing emails that actually convert, managing the sequences, and handling replies - that's where a lot of toy and game companies end up. It's faster, and you're not figuring it out from scratch. Either way, the important thing is actually getting started. Your product deserves to be in front of the right buyers.
Ready to Sign Clients On-Demand?
BEC Growth builds and manages your entire cold email system from infrastructure to reply handling.
Book a Call →