You've been sending cold emails for months. Your open rates look decent. You're getting replies. But your calendar is still dead, and you're not closing deals at the pace you need.
Here's what's probably happening - you're stopping too early in the conversation. Cold email is great at getting attention and starting a dialogue, but it's not designed to be your entire sales process. The moment someone doesn't reply to your third email, you ghost them. Or worse, you expect the whole sale to happen via email.
That's leaving money on the table.
The cold email and cold call combo isn't some fancy new strategy. It's just common sense - you're using email to do what it does best (start conversations at scale), and you're using calls to do what they do best (actually move deals forward). Let me walk you through how this actually works in practice.
Email is efficient. You can send 50 personalized emails in an hour. You can track opens and clicks. You can set up sequences that run while you sleep. It's scalable in a way that phone calls will never be.
But here's the thing - email is also easy to ignore. Someone gets your message, reads it, thinks "I'll look at this later," and then never does. They're not being rude. They're just busy. Your email disappears under 47 other emails that day.
A call forces a real-time decision. Either they pick up, or they don't. Either you have a conversation, or you leave a voicemail. There's friction, sure - but that friction often leads to clarity. People remember phone conversations. They take action after phone conversations.
The combo works because email does the heavy lifting (getting your name in front of hundreds of people), and calls do the closing (actually moving the people who are interested into a real conversation).
You're not jumping on the phone after the first email. That's desperate and it doesn't work. Send your initial email. Wait 3-4 days. If there's no open and no reply, send a follow-up email. Wait another 3-4 days. Send one more email.
At this point, you have three emails in someone's inbox. If they haven't opened any of them, they're probably not interested - or they're swamped and your message got buried. Either way, it's time to try a different channel.
If they've opened but not replied, that's actually interesting. They saw your message. Something didn't quite land, but they didn't delete it either. These are your prime call targets.
You're not calling everyone. That would be chaos. You're calling the people who showed interest by opening your emails, or the people in your list who have the highest-value potential.
Your script is simple. You're not trying to sell them on the call - you're trying to get a 15-minute conversation scheduled. That's it.
Something like: "Hey, I sent you a couple emails about [specific thing they care about]. I know you're busy, so I'll keep this quick - I think we could help you with [one specific outcome]. You got five minutes to talk through it?"
That's a conversation starter. Not a pitch. Not a sales call. Just a real human checking if there's mutual interest.
If someone agrees to a meeting but doesn't show up, send an email. If someone takes the call but says "maybe later," send an email. Email is great for keeping the door open and giving people something they can reference later.
The calls create momentum. The emails maintain it.
It's simple math. Email reaches more people but converts fewer of them. Calls close more of the people you reach, but you can't reach as many. Combined, you're hitting the sweet spot - broad reach with better conversion rates.
There's also a psychological element. When someone gets both an email and a call from you, it signals that you're serious. You're not just blasting emails and hoping something sticks. You're actually following up. You actually care. That matters more than people realize.
Plus, when you do get someone on the phone, you have context from the emails they've read (or haven't read). You can reference your previous messages. You can ask why they didn't reply. You can have a real conversation, not a cold call from a stranger.
You need a way to track email opens. If you don't know who opened your emails, you're shooting blind. Tools like Apollo, Outreach, or even HubSpot will do this.
You need a decent list. Garbage in, garbage out. If you're calling people who don't match your ideal customer, it doesn't matter how good your combo strategy is.
And you need time. Or at least, you need to be realistic about what this takes. If you're trying to do this yourself while running your business, it's a lot. Sending emails, tracking opens, calling people, scheduling meetings - it's not hard, but it's time-consuming.
Most businesses don't struggle with the strategy itself. They struggle with execution. They send emails but don't follow up consistently. They plan to make calls but never actually do it. They get three rejections and quit.
The combo only works if you actually run it. If you're inconsistent, you'll get inconsistent results. That's not a strategy problem - that's a discipline problem.
If you want this done right without the headache of managing it yourself, that's where having a team handle it makes sense. There are agencies that specialize in this - they manage the email sequences, they track the opens, they make the calls to the right people, and they do it all consistently month after month.
If you want to build this in-house, go for it. The strategy works. But if you'd rather hand this off to people who do it every day and have the infrastructure already built, that's worth considering too. Either way, the combo approach beats trying to close deals with email alone.
Ready to Sign Clients On-Demand?
BEC Growth builds and manages your entire cold email system from infrastructure to reply handling.
Book a Call →